Insurance Total-Loss Settlements Explained
If your car was totaled, your insurer may have left out taxes, fees or value. Here is how total-loss class action settlements work and what you need to claim.
Insurance total-loss settlements pay policyholders who had a vehicle declared a total loss and, according to the lawsuit, were paid less than their policy or state law required. The most common issues are leaving out sales tax and title or registration fees, or using valuation methods that lowered the car's value. If your car was totaled during the class period by an insurer that settled, you may get an additional payment, sometimes automatically.
How total-loss payments work
When an insurer decides a car costs too much to repair, it declares it a total loss and pays its actual cash value, which is roughly what a comparable vehicle would cost just before the loss. The details depend on your policy and your state's insurance rules. In many states, that payment can also need to include costs you would face to replace the car, like sales tax and certain fees.
What total-loss lawsuits claim
- ✓Missing sales tax: not including the sales tax you would pay on a replacement vehicle, where state law or the policy requires it.
- ✓Missing fees: leaving out title transfer, registration or similar fees.
- ✓Valuation adjustments: using third-party valuation reports with deductions, such as a negotiation adjustment or condition adjustments, that plaintiffs argue artificially lowered the value.
- ✓Leased vehicles: disputes over how payments were calculated for leased cars.
Whether an insurer owed tax, fees or a different valuation depends on your policy wording and your state's laws. That is why most total-loss settlements cover policyholders in one specific state.
Open total-loss settlements
Star Casualty Total Loss Settlement — Up to $279.85 for Florida Drivers
FL Star Casualty Total Loss Settlement — Up to $279.85 for Florida Drivers Unpaid title and tag transfer fees plus storage and towing deductions returned, with interest, for Florida drivers whose Star Casualty vehicle was totaled.
Progressive Colorado Total-Loss Settlement — $15.2M
CO Insurance Progressive Colorado Total-Loss Settlement — $15.2M 68% of the projected sold adjustment Progressive cut from a totaled vehicle payout, about $374 on a $20,000 car, for Colorado Direct and Preferred policyholders.
Updated daily from the SettleScout catalogue. See every open settlement.
Who qualifies
Classes are usually defined as policyholders, and sometimes claimants under someone else's policy, who received a total-loss payment for a vehicle from a named insurer, in a specific state, during a date range. Because the insurer has complete claims records, the administrator can often identify you directly.
Automatic payment or claim form?
Both happen. When the dispute is simple, such as a missing fee that is the same for everyone, the settlement may pay a fixed amount automatically to everyone on the insurer's list. When the dispute involves valuation, the payment may depend on the specific report, and you might need to file a claim or confirm details. Read the notice, and see automatic payment vs claim form settlements for the difference.
What you may need
- ✓Your claim number or policy number
- ✓The date of loss and vehicle details, such as the VIN
- ✓The settlement letter or valuation report from the insurer, if you still have it
- ✓A current mailing address and, if offered, an electronic payment method
How much they pay
Payments typically relate to the amount the lawsuit says was missing. A tax-and-fees case may pay a fixed fee amount, or a percentage of the tax owed based on your car's value. A valuation case may pay a portion of the disputed adjustment. Since the shortfall is tied to your specific claim, these can be larger than many consumer settlements, but amounts vary by case.
How to check your eligibility
- 1Think back to any car that was totaled in recent years and note the insurer, the state and the date.
- 2Check the open settlements above and the full settlement list for that insurer.
- 3If you find one, read the class definition and file or update your address before the deadline.
If you think your payout was too low but no case exists
You can ask your insurer how it calculated the value, request the valuation report and dispute it with comparable listings. Many policies include an appraisal process for disagreements over value. Your state insurance department also takes complaints. Those steps are separate from a class action and may get you more money sooner, but they do not prevent you from joining a settlement later if one is filed.
If someone else owned the car with you, or a lender held the title, the payment may be issued to more than one name, just as the original total-loss check was. The notice explains how co-owners and lienholders are handled. Make sure each owner's contact details are current with the administrator.
Car owners may also qualify for defect and fee settlements. See settlements for car owners. Add your auto insurers, past and present, to SettleScout, and it will tell you when a matching settlement opens and remind you before the deadline.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I claim if my car was totaled by someone else's insurer?
Sometimes. Some total-loss settlements include third-party claimants, people paid under the at-fault driver's policy, while others cover only the insurer's own policyholders. The class definition explains which applies.
Do I need my original total-loss paperwork?
Not usually. Insurers have their own claims records, and many total-loss settlements pay automatically. Keeping your claim number and settlement letter can help if the administrator asks for details.
Will a total-loss settlement raise my insurance rates?
Being a class member in a settlement should not count as a new insurance claim. If you are worried about your situation, contact the class counsel listed in the notice.
See every settlement you qualify for
Tell SettleScout which brands you use. It finds your matches, estimates your payouts and reminds you before deadlines.
Free to download